Paid Up

Guide · law

Passing card fees to clients: surcharge rules in the US and UK

In the UK you can't add a fee for paying by a personal card. In the US you usually can on credit cards, up to 3% and with notice, but not on debit cards and not in a handful of states. Here are the rules side by side, with worked examples on real bookings.

SWritten by Sam Ade · Facts checked Nov 17, 2026 · Updated

The short answer

  • UK: you can't charge a consumer extra for paying by a personal debit or credit card. This has been banned since 13 January 2018. Fees on corporate cards are allowed, but only up to what the card costs you.
  • US, credit cards: allowed in most states, on these terms:
    • no more than 3% (Visa), and no more than your actual card cost;
    • 30 days' written notice to your payment processor first;
    • clear signs or wording before the client pays;
    • the fee shown on the receipt.
  • US, debit and prepaid cards: never, even when run "as credit".
  • US states that ban or limit it: Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and Puerto Rico ban credit card surcharges. Colorado and Oklahoma cap them at 2%. New York, New Jersey, Minnesota and others add their own rules. See the table below.
  • Convenience fees don't fit payment plans. Visa doesn't allow them on recurring or installment payments.
  • Often the better move is to cut the fee, not pass it on. Offer bank debit (ACH or Direct Debit), which costs a few dollars or pounds per payment, or build the cost into your price.

US vs UK at a glance

Card surcharge rules in the US and the UK
QuestionUSUK
Surcharge on a personal credit card?Yes in most states, up to 3% and your costNo (reg 6A, since 13 Jan 2018)
Surcharge on a personal debit card?No (card network rules; some state laws too)No
Surcharge on a corporate / commercial card?Treated as credit: same network rulesYes, up to your cost for that card
Who sets the rules?Visa and Mastercard rules, plus state lawsThe Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012
Notice before you start30 days' written notice to your processor (Visa)None (no surcharge to give notice of)
Disclosure to the clientAt the entrance or first page and at checkout; on the receiptCorporate-card fee shown before payment; headline price rules apply
Fee for other methods (bank transfer, Direct Debit)?Not covered by card rules; state law and price-display laws applyAllowed up to cost for some methods (reg 4); sterling bank payments aren't in the 6A ban
Discount for paying by bank?Allowed (federal law protects cash discounts)Allowed

UK rules: the consumer card ban

The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 (SI 2012/3110) were amended from 13 January 2018 by the Payment Services Regulations 2017. The new regulation 6A bans any fee for paying by:

  • a card that isn't a commercial card. That covers consumer debit and credit cards, including, on our reading of the definition, consumer American Express cards;
  • similar non-card payment instruments used by consumers;
  • euro credit transfers and direct debits under the SEPA Regulation.

The ban follows the card, not the customer. A sole trader paying a venue deposit on their personal card is covered. A company paying on a corporate card isn't, but regulation 6A(2) still caps a fee on a commercial card at your actual cost for that card.

Regulation 6B adds a cross-border wrinkle. The full ban applies when both your payment provider and the client's are in the UK, which is nearly always the case for a UK business. Where only one is, the cost cap still applies.

For other payment methods, regulation 4 says fees charged to consumers can't exceed your cost. Bank transfers and Direct Debit are allowed in principle, but few businesses charge for them, and doing so would undercut the point of offering them. Fees that are the same whatever the payment method, like a booking fee, aren't payment surcharges. Since April 2025, though, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 requires unavoidable fees to be included in the headline price you advertise.

What to do in the UK

Don't add a card fee for clients paying personally. Build the card cost into your prices. Offer Direct Debit for instalments: through Stripe it's 1% capped at £4 a payment. If a corporate client pays by company card, you may add a fee up to your actual cost, shown before they pay. Direct Debit comes with its own mandate and the Direct Debit Guarantee.

Gov.uk's older guidance page on payment surcharges now appears to be archived. Trading Standards' Business Companion guide (reviewed April 2025) is the current plain-English source.

US card network rules

In the US, the main limits on surcharges come from the card networks' rules. You agree to these through your payment processor. These are Visa's rules as published on 24 October 2026:

Visa US credit card surcharge rules
RuleWhat it saysVisa rule
Credit onlySurcharging is allowed in the US and its territories for credit card transactions only. No debit or prepaid cards.1.5.5.2; definitions
NoticeTell your acquirer (your processor) in writing at least 30 calendar days before you announce or first charge a surcharge.5.5.1.5
Maximum3.00%, and no more than your own cost of accepting credit cards (your average merchant discount rate over the last 1 or 12 months).5.5.1.8
Brand or product levelYou can surcharge all Visa credit cards (brand level) or certain card products (product level), not both. The fee can't vary by bank.5.5.1.7
DisclosureClear notice at the point of entry and the point of sale: the amount or rate, that you charge it, that it's for credit only, and that it's no more than your cost. Online, phone or mail clients must be able to cancel after seeing it.5.5.1.9
ReceiptThe surcharge is part of the transaction amount and shows on the receipt.5.5.1.7; 11.13.4
RefundsRefund the surcharge too, pro rata for a partial refund.Visa Core Rules

Mastercard also allows credit card surcharges, with similar disclosure rules and no surcharging of debit cards. Its merchant page has long stated a maximum of 4%, or your cost if lower. We couldn't read Mastercard's current rule text directly, and its registration process has reportedly changed, so check both points with your processor. In practice most merchants apply one rate to both networks, and 3% keeps you inside Visa's cap.

American Express and Discover have their own surcharge terms. Visa's "similar treatment" rule (5.5.1.6) can also stop you surcharging Visa more heavily than a competing brand you take. Ask your processor for its current summary; we couldn't verify either network's current rule at source.

Why debit is off-limits. The ban on surcharging debit cards comes from the network rules, plus some state laws (Colorado, Oklahoma, Maine, Louisiana and Puerto Rico among them). It doesn't come from the federal Durbin Amendment, which is often cited for it. Durbin, at 15 U.S.C. 1693o-2, stops networks blocking discounts for paying by cash, check, debit or credit. It doesn't mention surcharges.

The Visa/Mastercard settlement: where it stands

US merchants have been suing Visa and Mastercard over card fees for nearly 20 years (MDL 1720, in New York). A March 2024 settlement was rejected by Judge Brodie in June 2024. A revised settlement was filed on 10 November 2025, and Judge Brian Cogan gave it preliminary approval in June 2026. Law-firm summaries say it would:

  • cap surcharges at 3% on both networks, which would bring Mastercard's down from 4%;
  • let merchants surcharge Visa or Mastercard without having to surcharge other brands;
  • let merchants accept or decline commercial, premium and standard consumer credit cards as separate categories, so you could refuse premium rewards cards;
  • reduce some interchange rates for several years;
  • take effect about 90 days after final approval.

Status on 17 November 2026: the final fairness hearing was held on 16 November 2026, and the judge didn't rule. There are more than 1,000 objections, including from large retailers, and appeals are expected. Until it is approved and the networks change their rules, today's rules apply. We'll update this page when the court rules.

US state laws on card surcharges

One table, so you can check your state and the states where your clients are. States not listed had no surcharge-specific law that we could confirm. General consumer-protection and price-display laws still apply everywhere. "Verified" means we read the statute or the state agency's own page; "summary" means we relied on bill digests or law-firm summaries.

US state credit card surcharge laws as of November 2026
StateRuleLawNotes
ConnecticutBanned; cash discounts and dual pricing allowedC.G.S. 42-133ff (amended by PA 24-142)Verified (Dept. of Consumer Protection). "Processing fee" or "non-cash adjustment" labels still count as surcharges.
MassachusettsBannedM.G.L. c.140D §28AVerified.
MaineBanned for credit and debit cards9-A M.R.S. §8-509Verified. A discount from the regular price isn't a surcharge.
Puerto RicoBanned for credit and debitLaw 150 of 2008Summary. Upheld by the 1st Circuit in 2025.
ColoradoCapped: 2% or your actual card cost, whichever is lower; no debitC.R.S. 5-2-212Ban repealed in 2022. Signage and a separate receipt line required.
OklahomaCapped from Nov 1, 2025: 2% or cost, whichever is lower; credit onlySB 677 (2025), 14A O.S. §2-211Summary. Notice in store, online and by phone. No surcharge if you accept only credit cards.
MinnesotaCapped at 5%, with noticeMinn. Stat. §325G.051Verified. Oral and posted notice in person; on screen online; oral by phone. Visa's 3% cap is stricter.
New YorkAllowed with conditions: post the total credit card price; no more than your card feeN.Y. Gen. Bus. Law §518 (revised 2024)Verified. Up to $500 per violation. Two-tier (cash/credit) pricing allowed.
New JerseyAllowed up to your actual processing cost, with disclosureN.J.S.A. 56:8-156.1 to 156.2 (P.L.2023, c.146)Summary. Disclose at entry, at the point of sale, online and by phone.
CaliforniaAllowed in practice, but no hidden feesCiv. Code §1748.1; §1770(a)(29) (SB 478, from Jul 1, 2024)The §1748.1 ban was held unconstitutional as applied in 2018. If you take only cards, the fee must be in the advertised price (Attorney General FAQ).
KansasAllowed with clear and conspicuous disclosureK.S.A. 16a-2-403 (from Jan 1, 2025)Summary. The earlier ban was held unconstitutional as applied in 2021.
TexasUnclear: ban on the booksBus. & Com. Code §604A.0021Summary. The State Law Library says enforceability is unclear after federal court rulings. Ask an attorney.
FloridaBan on the books, not enforcedFla. Stat. §501.0117Summary. Held unconstitutional by the 11th Circuit (2015). Separately, §509.214 requires caterers and restaurants to disclose "operations charges", including card surcharges, in event contracts.
LouisianaDebit surcharges banned from Aug 1, 2026Act 751 of 2026 (SB 254)Summary. Credit surcharges not affected.

Two court decisions explain why some bans are "on the books" but not enforced. In Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman (2017), the Supreme Court held that New York's law regulated speech: how a price is described. It sent the case back rather than striking the law down. Courts have since held the California, Florida, Kansas and Texas bans unconstitutional for some or all businesses. Several states then rewrote their laws as disclosure-and-cap rules. If you're in a state with a disputed law, the safest path is to offer a discount for other payment methods rather than a surcharge.

Which state applies when a client is elsewhere? Usually the law where you do business, but some state laws protect their own residents, so check both if you book many out-of-state clients. Wedding venues and caterers should also check local rules on service and "operations" charges.

Surcharge, cash discount, convenience fee or service fee?

The label you choose changes which rules apply. This is how Visa's rules and federal law draw the lines.

Kinds of payment fees and discounts and whether they suit a payment plan
What it isHow it worksRulesOn a payment plan?
SurchargeA percentage added when the client pays by credit cardVisa 3% cap, notice, disclosure; credit only; state lawsPossible where legal. Put it in the agreement and the card consent.
Cash / bank discountThe posted price is the card price, and clients paying by bank, cash or check pay lessProtected by 15 U.S.C. 1666f and the Durbin Amendment; Regulation Z treats the posted "regular price" as the reference pointYes. The cleanest option in most states, including Connecticut and Maine.
Convenience feeA flat fee for paying through an unusual channelVisa 5.5.2.1: flat amount, all payment types in that channel, never with a surcharge, not on recurring or installment paymentsNo.
Service feeA Visa program for government and education merchantsVisa 5.5.3.1, certain merchant types onlyNot for private businesses.
Booking or admin feeA fee charged whatever the payment methodNot a payment surcharge, but junk-fee and price-display laws (California SB 478, the UK DMCC Act) require it in the headline priceYes, if it's in the quoted price.

Worked examples

1. An $8,000 photography booking in New York

A $2,000 deposit and four $1,500 instalments, all by credit card. On Stripe's standard 2.9% + 30¢, the card fees are $58.30 on the deposit and $43.80 on each instalment: $233.50 in total (rates checked Nov 16, 2026).

New York allows a surcharge up to your card cost if the credit card price is posted. At 2.9% that's $58 on the deposit and $43.50 on each instalment, $232 in all. The quote and agreement must show the full card price ($8,232) next to the price for paying by bank ($8,000). If the client's card turns out to be a debit card, no surcharge is allowed on it.

If the client pays by ACH instead, Stripe's fees are capped at $5 a payment: $25.00 in total. Many photographers find it simpler to say: "Pay by bank at no extra cost, or by credit card with a 2.9% fee."

2. The same booking in Colorado, Massachusetts or Connecticut

  • Colorado: the cap is 2% or your cost, whichever is lower. That's $40 on the deposit and $30 per instalment, $160 in all, which leaves about $73 of the card cost with you.
  • Massachusetts: no surcharge at all.
  • Connecticut: no surcharge either. You can post $8,000 as the price and offer 2.9% off for paying by bank ($7,768). The state's consumer protection department describes exactly this cash-discount approach. Calling the difference a "non-cash adjustment" on top of a lower price would still count as a surcharge.

3. A £6,000 wedding in England

Four £1,500 payments by personal card cost £90.80 on Stripe's standard UK rate of 1.5% + 20p. You can't pass any of that to the couple. By Bacs Direct Debit (1% capped at £4) the same payments cost £16.00. If the couple's parent pays one instalment on a company credit card, you could add a fee for that payment up to its actual cost. Most venues don't bother.

4. A $30,000 venue booking where the client wants card points

By card, processing on $30,000 is about $870. A 3% surcharge would be $900, more than your cost, so it breaks Visa's rule that the surcharge can't exceed your cost of acceptance. Price the surcharge at your real rate. Better still, offer ACH at no fee and let the client decide whether the points are worth 2.9% to them.

Better alternatives to a surcharge

  1. 1

    Offer bank debit on every plan

    ACH costs 0.8% capped at $5 on Stripe. UK Direct Debit costs 1% capped at £4. On a $15,000 plan, ACH saves about $400 against cards, and no surcharge rules apply. See ACH payment plans for the timing trade-offs.

  2. 2

    Build the card cost into your price

    If most clients pay by card, a price about 3% higher covers it, with no signs, notices or state rules. It's the only option in the UK for consumer cards.

  3. 3

    Give a discount for paying by bank or in full

    Quote the card price, then take a discount off it for bank payment or for paying in full up front. Federal law protects discounts, and they work in states that ban surcharges.

  4. 4

    Take the deposit by card and the rest by bank

    A card deposit confirms instantly. The large instalments then go by bank, where the fee is capped.

Whichever you choose, put it in writing: in the quote, the payment plan agreement and the card consent at checkout. Visa expects any surcharge to be in the stored-card agreement (see card authorization wording).

How Paid Up handles card fees

Paid Up charges the amounts in your schedule. It doesn't add a card surcharge to payments, and it doesn't check your state's law or give your processor surcharge notice. UK businesses can't set a card fee at all.

What Paid Up does offer is the alternative. US clients can choose bank debit (ACH) on any plan; UK clients pay by card until UK Direct Debit is switched on. The payment page shows that bank payments carry no extra fee, and for US clients you can take the deposit by card and the rest by bank.

Our own fee is the same for card and bank: 0.5% per payment on Free or 0.25% on Plus, plus Stripe's fees. See pricing for the totals.

Questions people ask

Is it legal to charge a credit card fee in the US?

In most states, yes, on credit cards only, if you follow the card networks' rules: Visa caps it at 3% and at your actual cost, and requires notice to your processor 30 days ahead and clear disclosure. Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and Puerto Rico ban surcharges; Colorado and Oklahoma cap them at 2%. You can't surcharge debit or prepaid cards anywhere.

Can I charge a card fee in the UK?

Not on personal (consumer) debit or credit cards: that has been banned since 13 January 2018. You can add a fee for a corporate or commercial card, but no more than what that card costs you, and the fee must be clear before the client pays.

Can I surcharge a debit card if the client presses 'credit'?

No. Visa's rules say a debit card can't be surcharged even if it's processed as credit, and the same applies to prepaid cards. Your checkout needs to tell debit from credit, which most processors do from the card number.

What's the difference between a surcharge and a convenience fee?

A surcharge is added because the client pays by credit card. A convenience fee, under Visa's rules, is a flat fee for paying through an unusual channel (say, by phone when you normally take payment in person) and applies to all payment types in that channel. Visa doesn't allow convenience fees on recurring or installment payments, so they don't work for payment plans.

Is a cash discount the same as a surcharge?

Legally they can be different. Federal law protects discounts for paying by cash or check, and Regulation Z looks at your posted 'regular price' to decide which you're offering. If the posted price is the card price and bank or cash payers get money off, it's a discount. Some states, such as Connecticut, look past the label, so the presentation matters.

Has the Visa and Mastercard settlement changed the rules yet?

Not as of 17 November 2026. The revised settlement got preliminary approval in June 2026 and the final fairness hearing was on 16 November 2026, with no ruling yet. If approved, it would set a 3% cap across both networks and let merchants decline premium cards, about 90 days after approval and subject to appeals.

Sources

  1. The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, reg 6A (legislation.gov.uk): ban on fees for consumer card payments from 13 Jan 2018; commercial cards capped at cost (read Nov 17, 2026)
  2. The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, reg 6B (legislation.gov.uk): the full ban applies when both payment providers are in the UK (read Nov 17, 2026)
  3. The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, reg 4 (legislation.gov.uk): fees for other payment methods may not exceed the trader's cost (read Nov 17, 2026)
  4. Business Companion (Trading Standards), Payment surcharges: personal vs corporate cards; headline price rules under the DMCC Act 2024 (reviewed Apr 2025) (read Nov 17, 2026)
  5. Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (24 Oct 2026): 1.5.5.2 US credit exemption; 5.5.1.5 30 days' notice to acquirer; 5.5.1.8 3% maximum; 5.5.1.9 disclosure; 5.5.2.1 convenience fees (not on recurring or installment) (read Nov 17, 2026)
  6. Visa, Visa rules and policies (surcharging Q&A): surcharging permitted on credit cards in most states (read Nov 17, 2026)
  7. America's Credit Unions, Court grants preliminary approval of interchange settlement (Jun 10, 2026): preliminary approval of the revised Visa/Mastercard merchant settlement (read Nov 17, 2026)
  8. Reuters via Investing.com, Visa, Mastercard urge approval of swipe fee settlement (Nov 16, 2026): fairness hearing held; no ruling yet (read Nov 17, 2026)
  9. Arnall Golden Gregory, the latest proposed Visa/Mastercard settlement and surcharging (Nov 24, 2025): proposed 3% cap across both networks and card-category acceptance (law-firm summary) (read Nov 17, 2026)
  10. Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection, Credit card surcharges: surcharges banned; cash discounts and dual pricing allowed (C.G.S. 42-133ff) (read Nov 17, 2026)
  11. Massachusetts General Laws c.140D s.28A: no seller may impose a surcharge on a cardholder (read Nov 17, 2026)
  12. Maine Revised Statutes 9-A s.8-509: no surcharge for paying by credit or debit card (read Nov 17, 2026)
  13. New York General Business Law s.518: post the total credit card price; surcharge no more than the card fee; $500 per violation (read Nov 17, 2026)
  14. Minnesota Statutes s.325G.051: surcharge up to 5% with notice (read Nov 17, 2026)
  15. California Attorney General, SB 478 hidden fees FAQ: an avoidable card fee need not be in the advertised price; if you take only cards, it must be (read Nov 17, 2026)
  16. 15 U.S.C. 1666f, cash discounts (Cornell LII): card issuers can't stop cash discounts (read Nov 17, 2026)
  17. Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.4 and commentary (CFPB): the 'regular price' decides whether a difference is a discount or a surcharge (read Nov 17, 2026)
  18. 15 U.S.C. 1693o-2, the Durbin Amendment (Cornell LII): protects discounts by payment type; doesn't itself ban debit surcharges (read Nov 17, 2026)

About this page

General information, not legal advice. Card network rules and state surcharge laws change often, and some state statutes are on the books but not enforced after court rulings; where we relied on summaries rather than the statute or rule text, the table says so. Before adding any card fee, check your processor's terms and ask an attorney (US) or solicitor (UK) about your state or situation. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at [email protected] and we'll correct it.

Cut the card fee instead of passing it on.

US clients can choose bank debit (ACH) on any plan, with Stripe's fee capped at $5 a payment; UK clients pay by card until UK Direct Debit is switched on. Start on the Free plan.