Guide
Disputed deposits: card chargebacks and Direct Debit claims on bookings
A disputed deposit is decided by the client's bank, not by you, and the rules depend on how they paid. Cards let you fight back with evidence; US bank debits and UK Direct Debits through most providers mostly don't. Your best defence is signed terms, a clear cancellation policy and a paper trail, set up before the first payment.
SWritten by Sam Ade · Facts checked Nov 17, 2026 · Updated
The short answer
- Card payments: the client's bank decides, but you can respond with evidence. For a future event, the dispute window usually starts on the event date, so a deposit can be disputed long after it was paid. You typically get 7–21 days to respond.
- US bank debits (ACH): a consumer has 60 days to dispute, and you can't contest it through the ACH network. Your remedy is the contract: invoice the client or pursue them for what they owe.
- UK Direct Debit: the Direct Debit Guarantee is meant for payment errors, not "I changed my mind". But the bank refunds first, and on Stripe you can't contest a Bacs dispute. Providers with their own dispute route (such as GoCardless) give you about 9 days to challenge.
- UK credit cards: Section 75 makes the card issuer jointly liable if you break the contract, for bookings between £100 and £30,000, even if only the deposit went on the card.
- What wins: signed terms with the cancellation policy, proof the client accepted them (time, IP address), reminders before each payment, and your messages showing you were ready to deliver.
By payment method: who decides and what you can do
| How the client paid | Window to dispute | Who decides | Can you respond? | Stripe fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Card (US or UK), chargeback | Typically 120 days; for future services usually from the event date | The card issuer, under Visa / Mastercard / Amex rules | Yes, with evidence, usually within 7–21 days | $15 + $15 if you counter (US); £20 + £20 (UK). Counter fee refunded if you win |
| UK credit card, Section 75 | A legal claim; ordinary limitation periods (generally 6 years in England and Wales) | The card issuer; then the Financial Ombudsman Service | Indirectly: the issuer may ask you, and can pursue you afterwards | None from Stripe unless it becomes a chargeback |
| US ACH debit | 60 calendar days (personal accounts); 2 business days (business accounts) | The client's bank | No. Only "proof of authorization" inquiries on rare late returns | $15 |
| UK Direct Debit via Stripe | No set time limit | The client's bank | No evidence or appeal on Stripe | £5 |
| UK Direct Debit via your own SUN or GoCardless | No set time limit (Guarantee) | The client's bank, after an indemnity claim (DDICA) | Yes, usually within 9 days of the DDICA | Varies by provider |
A UK credit card claim under Section 75 is a legal claim with ordinary limitation periods, so it isn't on this scale.
Sources: Stripe dispute, ACH and Bacs documentation and Stripe pricing (read Nov 17, 2026); GoCardless's indemnity claim guide; Consumer Credit Act 1974 s.75. The Section 75 time limit is a general note, not legal advice.
Card chargebacks on a booking
When a client disputes a card payment, Stripe takes the disputed amount plus the dispute fee from your balance straight away and holds it until the bank decides. You can't refund the charge separately while the dispute is open. You then either accept the dispute or submit evidence. Stripe says the issuer usually takes 60–75 days to decide after you respond, and the whole process often takes 2–3 months (Stripe, How disputes work).
The timing trap for bookings. Card networks typically allow disputes within 120 days of the payment. But Stripe notes that when a customer pays for a future event or service, "the dispute window starts on the event date, not the payment date". Secondary sources describing Visa's rules give an outer limit of 540 days from the original transaction. In practice: a deposit taken 14 months before a wedding can be disputed until about four months after the wedding. Keep your records for at least that long.
Disputes on several instalments. If a client disputes several payments from one plan, Stripe says their bank sometimes files one dispute for the total against a single charge. Check the amount before you respond; it may be bigger than the payment it's attached to.
Withdrawn disputes still need a response. If the client calls their bank and withdraws the dispute after talking to you, Stripe says you must still submit evidence for it to close in your favor. Upload a short note and the client's written confirmation that they've withdrawn it.
Reason codes you'll see, and what wins
Each network uses its own codes; Stripe groups them into categories. These are the ones that come up on deposits and instalments.
| Client's claim | Visa | Mastercard | Evidence that answers it |
|---|---|---|---|
| "I cancelled, but you kept charging the plan" | 13.2 Canceled Recurring | 4841 Canceled Recurring | Signed schedule; proof no cancellation was received before the charge (or that the charge was due under your cancellation terms); reminder emails sent before it |
| "I cancelled the booking and should get money back" | 13.7 Canceled Merchandise/Services | 4853 Cardholder Dispute | Cancellation policy the client accepted, with timestamp; the date and wording of their cancellation; your calculation under the policy; any partial refund you issued |
| "The service wasn't provided" | 13.1 Services Not Received | 4853 (formerly 4855 Goods or Services Not Provided) | If the date hasn't happened: the event date and proof you're ready to deliver. If it has: proof of delivery (gallery delivered, timeline, photos, check-in records) |
| "I was promised a refund" | 13.6 Credit Not Processed | 4860 Credit Not Processed | Your refund policy and the client's acceptance; messages showing no refund was promised, or proof the refund was made |
| "I didn't authorize this" | 10.4 Other Fraud, Card-Absent | 4837 No Cardholder Authorization | Signature record (IP, device, time); 3D Secure result if used; earlier undisputed payments on the same card; emails with the client about the booking |
Codes and evidence examples from Stripe's dispute reason codes guide, read Nov 17, 2026. Mastercard has folded several older codes into 4853; Stripe's guide still lists 4855.
The "not yet provided" dispute. A client who disputes an instalment for a wedding six months away is claiming "services not received" for services that aren't due yet. Your response is short: the agreed date, the signed terms, and a statement that you're ready and able to deliver. Ask the client directly too: these disputes are often a sign they want to cancel and haven't said so.
Two worked examples
1. The charge you shouldn't have taken (US). A planner books a $7,200 wedding for Saturday, September 25, 2027: $1,800 deposit, then six $900 card payments on the 1st of each month from March to August. On May 29, 119 days before the wedding, the couple email: "We've called off the wedding." The planner's terms say the deposit is non-refundable and cancellations 60–120 days out owe 50% of the total. The planner doesn't pause the plan, and the $900 instalment is charged on Jun 1. The couple dispute it as "canceled recurring" (Visa 13.2).
This one is hard to win: the client cancelled in writing before the charge. The better path was to stop the schedule on May 29, then work out the cancellation under the terms: 50% of $7,200 = $3,600 owed; paid so far $1,800 + 3 × $900 = $4,500; refund $900. If the planner had done that, there'd be nothing to dispute. Lesson: a cancellation stops automatic payments the same day; what's still owed is settled under your terms, not by the next scheduled charge.
2. The dispute you can answer (UK). A venue books a £12,000 wedding for Saturday 4 September 2027. The couple pay a £3,000 deposit by credit card and the rest by Direct Debit. In March 2027 they postpone to 2028, the venue offers the only free 2028 Saturday they have, the couple decline it, then dispute the £3,000 card deposit as "cancelled services". The venue responds with: the signed terms (accepted online on a recorded date and time, with IP address), the clause on postponement and the non-refundable deposit, the emails offering a new date, and a note that the event date hasn't passed and the venue was ready to deliver. Because the couple paid by credit card, they could also try Section 75. That only works if the venue broke the contract or misrepresented something; a fair cancellation term the couple accepted isn't a breach.
US bank debits (ACH)
ACH debits are cheap, but disputes are one-sided. Stripe's ACH documentation says a customer can generally dispute through their bank for up to 60 calendar days after a debit on a personal account (2 business days for a business account), that these disputes "are final and can't be contested through the ACH network", and that the dispute fee isn't refunded (Stripe, ACH Direct Debit). Behind this is Regulation E: a consumer reports an unauthorized transfer within 60 days of the statement that shows it (12 CFR 1005.6).
Two more consequences matter for payment plans:
- The authorization dies. A dispute invalidates the mandate, so every later instalment fails until the client authorizes again. If they dispute a second payment, Stripe blocks the bank account.
- Refund plus dispute can pay twice. If you refund while the client's bank is also processing a dispute, the client can be credited twice. Agree in writing which route you're using.
Your recourse after a lost ACH dispute is ordinary contract law: send a written statement of what's owed under the signed agreement, ask the client to pay by another method, and, for larger amounts, consider small claims court. That's also why many US businesses take the deposit by card (disputable, but contestable) and the instalments by ACH (cheap, but not contestable).
UK Direct Debit: what the Guarantee covers
Every Direct Debit carries the Direct Debit Guarantee. Its key promise: if an error is made in the payment by the organisation or the bank, the payer "is entitled to a full and immediate refund". It also says changes to amount, date or frequency are notified "normally 10 working days" in advance "or as otherwise agreed", and that a payer who gets a refund they're not entitled to must pay it back when asked. The scheme's own explanation adds that the Guarantee doesn't affect the contract with the biller (directdebit.co.uk).
Not for contract disputes. The Financial Ombudsman Service has said this repeatedly. In DRN-5364747 (Santander, March 2025) the ombudsman wrote that the Guarantee covers processing errors and "doesn't however, address contractual disputes" between payer and biller, and upheld the bank's refusal. In DRN-5837191 (NatWest, January 2026) a bank fairly declined to raise an indemnity claim because it looked like "a contractual dispute, more so than an error". These are individual decisions, not binding precedent, but they show how banks are expected to treat "I changed my mind about the booking" claims.
How a claim reaches you. The payer asks their bank for a refund; the bank refunds them, then raises a Direct Debit Indemnity Claim against the business through a DDICA report. GoCardless says the business has 9 days to dispute the claim and claims are usually collected within 14 days (GoCardless). To win, you show the debit matched the advance notice: right amount, right date, valid mandate.
On Stripe it's different. Stripe's Bacs documentation says there's no set time limit for Bacs disputes, that you "can't submit evidence or counter" one, and that the bank's decision is final (Stripe, Bacs Direct Debit). Stripe also warns that because the indemnity period is open-ended, a client can dispute even after you've refunded them, so you can lose both. If a Bacs payment is clawed back, your route is the same as ACH: the contract.
Take the deposit by card, where you can answer a dispute with evidence, and use Direct Debit for the instalments, where the fee is low (1%, capped at £4 on Stripe) and the Guarantee isn't meant for change-of-mind claims. Send advance notice of every collection and never collect a different amount or date from the one notified: those mismatches are the errors the Guarantee does cover.
UK credit and debit cards: Section 75 and chargeback
Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 makes a UK credit card issuer jointly liable with the supplier for "any claim" for misrepresentation or breach of contract. It applies when the cash price of the item is over £100 and not more than £30,000 (legislation.gov.uk). Citizens Advice explains that it applies "if you paid any part of the cost by credit card", using an example where a £50 card deposit let the buyer claim the full £250 (Citizens Advice).
For a business that means:
- A £500 credit card deposit on a £6,000 photography package brings the whole £6,000 booking inside Section 75.
- A £35,000 wedding (cash price over £30,000) is outside Section 75, though card chargeback may still apply.
- Section 75 is about your breach or misrepresentation: you cancel, you go out of business, you don't deliver what you described. A client who cancels under fair terms they agreed to doesn't have a breach claim. If the issuer pays out, it can seek to recover the money from you.
- If the client isn't happy with the issuer's answer, they can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
UK debit cards have no Section 75 cover. Instead, the client asks for a chargeback under card scheme rules, which Citizens Advice describes as a voluntary scheme rather than a legal right. For you it works like the card chargebacks above: the same reason codes, the same evidence, the same Stripe fees.
Evidence checklist
Collect this when the booking is made, not when the dispute arrives. Most of it can't be recreated later.
- The signed agreement: the full text the client saw, with the deposit, the schedule, the cancellation tiers and the refund terms.
- Proof of acceptance: date and time, IP address, device or browser, and the exact version of the terms. A typed-name signature or tick box with this record is far stronger than "they replied OK".
- The payment authorization: for cards, consent to store the card and charge the schedule; for ACH, the mandate wording; for Direct Debit, the mandate and Guarantee shown.
- Notices before each payment: reminders with amount and date, and for Bacs, the advance notice.
- Receipts for each payment taken.
- Communications: emails or messages about the booking, especially any cancellation, postponement or refund request, with dates.
- Readiness or delivery: for a future date, confirmation the date is still held for them; after the event, proof of delivery.
- Your cancellation calculation: if they cancelled, the figures under your policy and what you refunded.
Write a one-page cover note in plain words: who the client is, what they booked, for what date, what they agreed, what happened and why the charge is valid. Put the key clause on page one, quoted exactly.
Preventing disputes in the first place
- A recognizable statement name. Many "fraud" disputes are clients who don't recognize the charge. Use your trading name as the card statement descriptor.
- Remind before every charge. A client who knew the payment was coming rarely calls it unauthorized.
- Make cancelling easy and written. Give a clear way to cancel, confirm it in writing with the figures, and stop scheduled payments the same day.
- Refund fast when you owe money. A refund issued before a dispute costs you nothing extra; a lost dispute costs the payment plus the fee.
- Talk first. When a client goes quiet after a failed payment, it's often the step before a dispute. See what to do when an instalment is missed.
- Keep records past the event. Card dispute windows can run months after the event date.
How Paid Up helps
Paid Up builds most of the evidence checklist as a side effect of taking the booking:
- Signature record: when a client agrees to their plan, Paid Up stores the exact text they agreed to, a SHA-256 fingerprint of it, the consent wording, the time, their IP address and browser, and which version of the terms and schedule it was. If a booking is changed later, the client agrees again and that's recorded too.
- Every email kept: the payment link, the reminders 7 and 3 days before each automatic payment, each receipt and each failed-payment notice are stored with their subject and body.
- UK split: UK Direct Debit is coming; until then UK clients pay by card. Once it's switched on, UK clients will pay the deposit by card and set up Direct Debit for the rest, matching the split described above.
Limits: Paid Up doesn't answer disputes for you. Payments run through your own Stripe account, so disputes appear in your Stripe Dashboard and you submit the evidence there; Stripe's dispute fees apply. Disputes are a risk signal for us too: a run of them on one account can bring back new-account limits while we review it.
Questions people ask
Can a client do a chargeback on a non-refundable deposit?
They can file one; whether it succeeds is up to their bank. If the client signed terms that clearly said the deposit was non-refundable, you didn't cancel, and you can show it, you have a reasonable chance of winning a card dispute. You can't contest a US ACH dispute or a Bacs dispute through Stripe at all, so for those your protection is the contract, not the dispute process.
How long does a client have to dispute a deposit?
For card payments the networks typically allow about 120 days, and for a future event Stripe says the window usually starts on the event date, not the payment date. So a deposit paid a year before a wedding can still be disputed months after the wedding. US consumers have 60 days to dispute an ACH debit; Bacs Direct Debit disputes have no set time limit.
Do I get the dispute fee back if I win?
On Stripe, the dispute received fee ($15 in the US, £20 in the UK) isn't refunded. Since June 2025 there's also a countered fee of the same amount when you submit evidence, and that one is returned if you win.
Should I refund the client if they've already filed a chargeback?
Not outside the dispute: Stripe doesn't let you refund a charge while its dispute is open. If you agree the client is owed money, accept the dispute instead. For ACH and Bacs, refunding while the bank also processes a claim can pay the client twice, so agree with the client which route you're using.
Does the Direct Debit Guarantee let a client reclaim a deposit because they changed their mind?
It shouldn't. The Guarantee is for errors in the payment, such as the wrong amount or date, and Financial Ombudsman decisions say it isn't meant for contractual disputes. In practice, though, the bank refunds first, and if you collect through Stripe you can't contest the claim, so a client who says 'error' may still get the money back.
Is a booking deposit covered by Section 75?
Yes, if the client paid any part by UK credit card and the booking's cash price is over £100 and not more than £30,000. The card issuer becomes jointly liable for your breach of contract or misrepresentation, so if you cancel or don't deliver, the client can claim the whole loss from their card issuer, not just the deposit.
Sources
- Stripe: How disputes work: 120-day typical window, starts on the event date for future services; 7-21 days to respond; 60-75 days to decide (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Stripe: Dispute reason codes: Visa 13.1, 13.2, 13.6, 13.7, 10.4 and Mastercard 4837, 4841, 4853, 4855, 4860 with evidence examples (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Stripe: June 2025 pricing updates for disputes: dispute fee and countered fee: $15 + $15 (US), £20 + £20 (UK); countered fee returned if you win (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Stripe: ACH Direct Debit (disputes): 60 calendar days for personal accounts, 2 business days for business accounts; can't be contested; mandate invalidated (read Nov 17, 2026)
- 12 CFR 1005.6 (Regulation E), CFPB: consumer reports unauthorized transfers within 60 days of the statement (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Stripe: Bacs Direct Debit (disputes and refunds): no time limit for Bacs disputes, no evidence or appeal on Stripe, refund-plus-dispute double credit risk (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Direct Debit: The Direct Debit Guarantee: Guarantee wording; doesn't affect the contract with the biller (read Nov 17, 2026)
- GoCardless: What is an indemnity claim?: DDICA report, 9 days to dispute, usually collected within 14 days (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Financial Ombudsman Service decision DRN-5364747 (Santander, 11 Mar 2025): the Guarantee covers payment errors, not contractual disputes (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Financial Ombudsman Service decision DRN-5837191 (NatWest, Jan 2026): bank fairly declined to raise a claim that was a contractual dispute more than an error (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Consumer Credit Act 1974, s.75: card issuer jointly liable; cash price over £100 and not more than £30,000 (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Citizens Advice: Getting your money back if you paid by card or PayPal: Section 75 applies if any part was paid by credit card; chargeback for debit cards (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Stripe pricing (UK): Bacs Direct Debit: £5 per disputed Bacs payment (read Nov 17, 2026)
About this page
General information, not legal advice. Card scheme rules, Nacha rules and Bacs scheme rules change, and dispute outcomes are decided case by case by the client's bank. Check current rules with your payment provider and take advice from an attorney or solicitor on your own terms. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at [email protected] and we'll correct it.
Have the signed terms ready before the first payment.
Paid Up records exactly what each client agreed to, when and from where, and keeps every reminder and receipt it sent.