Guide · law
Non-refundable deposits: when you can legally keep one
Usually you can keep a non-refundable deposit if it is a modest amount that genuinely holds a date and the client agreed to it in writing before paying. You usually can't keep a large one, money for work you never had to do, or anything when you are the one who cancels. Here is how US and UK law decide, with examples.
SWritten by Sam Ade · Facts checked Nov 17, 2026 · Updated
The short answer
- The label doesn't decide it. In both countries a court asks what the money is for and whether the amount is proportionate. A sum paid "as a deposit" can still be a penalty (Cavendish v Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67, para 16).
- UK: you can usually keep a deposit if it is a genuine reservation fee, "a small percentage of the price", agreed clearly before payment, and lost only in "clear and narrow" circumstances (CMA37, para 6.62). Bigger non-refundable sums must match your real net loss.
- US: you can usually keep a deposit that works as reasonable liquidated damages: a fair estimate, made at signing, of a loss that is hard to measure. An unreasonably large amount is a penalty and unenforceable. California is stricter for consumer contracts.
- Never keep it when you cancel or can't provide the service. In the UK, also expect to refund it when the event becomes impossible through nobody's fault (CMA37, para 6.77).
- Keep evidence: the enquiries you turned away, what you spent, and whether you rebooked the date. That is what wins disputes.
This page is the law. To write the policy itself, use the deposit and cancellation policy generator; to size the deposit, see how much deposit to charge.
UK: the fairness test
When you sell to consumers in the UK, every term of your contract must be fair under Part 2 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015. A term is unfair "if, contrary to the requirement of good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations under the contract to the detriment of the consumer" (section 62(4)). Fairness is judged on the nature of what is sold, all the circumstances when the term was agreed, and the rest of the contract (section 62(5)). An unfair term "is not binding on the consumer" (section 62(1)).
Three entries on the Act's "grey list" of terms that may be unfair (Schedule 2, Part 1) are aimed squarely at non-refundable deposits:
| Grey list | The kind of term | What it means for a deposit |
|---|---|---|
| Para 4 | Lets the business keep sums paid when the consumer decides not to go ahead, without giving the consumer equivalent compensation when the business cancels | A deposit that is lost if the client cancels but simply refunded (with nothing more) if you cancel is one-sided. At minimum, refund everything if you cancel. |
| Para 5 | Makes a consumer who decides not to go ahead pay "a disproportionately high sum in compensation or for services which have not been supplied" | A deposit far above what reserving the date is worth, or charging for work you no longer have to do. |
| Para 6 | Makes a consumer who fails to meet their obligations pay "a disproportionately high sum in compensation" | Forfeiting large sums when a client misses one instalment. |
A grey-list term isn't automatically unfair, but the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) and courts start from suspicion. The CMA's guidance on unfair terms (CMA37, revised July 2026) spells out how it reads them for prepayments.
What the CMA says about deposits
The key passage is paragraph 6.62. Terms letting a business keep prepayments when the consumer cancels are more likely to be fair if the consumer is at fault and the business keeps what it reasonably needs to cover "unavoidable net costs or the net loss of profit resulting directly from the default". And:
"A genuine deposit may legitimately be kept in full as long as it operates as a binding reservation and the trader makes clear to the consumer at the earliest opportunity that a deposit is required, and the precise circumstances in which it would be non-refundable. Those circumstances must be clear and narrow ... But such a deposit will not normally be more than a small percentage of the price. A larger prepayment is more likely to be unfair as it may amount to a disguised penalty."
The opposite case is in paragraph 6.60: a term making "any substantial prepayment entirely non-refundable, regardless of the circumstances or the amount of costs and losses caused by termination" is more likely to be unfair. The CMA's 2016 letter to wedding and event venues put it in one line: deposits are more likely to be fair where they "act as a reservation fee for the services and so are a small percentage of the total price".
So the UK position has two layers. A small reservation deposit can be kept in full when the client cancels. Anything more, whether called a deposit, an advance payment or a booking fee, can only be kept to the extent it matches your net loss: the profit you lose, minus the costs you save and anything you recover by reselling the date.
UK: the penalty rule
Separately from consumer law, English common law refuses to enforce penalty clauses in any contract, consumer or business. The modern test comes from the Supreme Court in Cavendish Square Holding v Makdessi; ParkingEye v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67. At paragraph 32: "The true test is whether the impugned provision is a secondary obligation which imposes a detriment on the contract-breaker out of all proportion to any legitimate interest of the innocent party in the enforcement of the primary obligation."
Two points in the judgment matter for deposits:
- A deposit can be a penalty. The fact that a sum is paid over as a deposit "does not prevent the sum being a penalty" (para 16).
- Customary deposits get leeway; big ones need a reason. The court discussed Workers Trust & Merchant Bank v Dojap Investments [1993], where the Privy Council accepted a forfeitable 10% deposit on a land sale as customary but struck down 25%. A seller wanting a larger forfeitable deposit "must show special circumstances which justify such a deposit" (para 35).
The 10% figure comes from land sales in Jamaica, not services, so don't treat it as a rule for your business. The lesson carries over, though: a deposit near what is normal in your trade, with a reason behind it, is far safer than an outlier. The CMA adds that a term can be unfair under the Consumer Rights Act even when it isn't a penalty at common law (CMA37, para 6.63, note 257), so passing one test doesn't mean you pass the other.
Scotland has its own law of contract, but the Consumer Rights Act applies across the UK, and the CMA guidance cites Scottish cases too. If you trade in Scotland or Northern Ireland, have a local solicitor check your terms.
What UK courts and Trading Standards look at
Only a court can decide that a term is unfair, but the CMA and local Trading Standards can act against businesses that rely on unfair terms, and since the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 the CMA can enforce directly, with penalties "of up to 10% of their business' global turnover or £300,000 (whichever is greater)" (CMA37, para 1.11). Unfair terms don't bind consumers, and a business "may have to repay money paid by consumers under such terms" (para 1.12). In practice, most deposit disputes are decided in the small claims court on these questions:
- How big is it? A small share of the price, or a fixed sum close to what's normal in your trade, is in the safe zone. A third or half of the price, kept a year before the date, is not.
- Was it clear before payment? The CMA wants the deposit flagged "at the earliest opportunity", with the circumstances in which it is lost stated precisely. A clause on page 9 doesn't count.
- Who ended the contract, and why? A deposit is only kept when the consumer is at fault. If you cancel, or the event becomes impossible, the client gets it back (paras 6.61, 6.77).
- What did the cancellation actually cost? Costs you couldn't avoid, profit you lost, minus savings and any rebooking. The CMA says charging both costs and lost profit can pay you twice (para 6.63).
- Is the deposit the only thing kept? A small deposit plus a fair sliding scale is fine. A deposit plus "all payments non-refundable" plus "the full balance becomes due" stacks up to double recovery.
- Was it really a choice? Terms the client couldn't negotiate and didn't see in time get stricter treatment.
Citizens Advice tells consumers they are "unlikely to get all your money back unless there's a generous cancellation clause", but that a business can keep some or all of a deposit "to compensate for their financial loss", and to negotiate if it is holding more than that (Citizens Advice). Expect clients to arrive with that advice in hand.
US: liquidated damages or penalty
US law has no national rule on deposits for services. A non-refundable deposit is a contract term, and courts in every state treat money kept on cancellation as liquidated damages: an amount the parties agree in advance as compensation for a breach. They enforce it if it is reasonable and strike it down as a penalty if it isn't.
The clearest statutory statement is in the Uniform Commercial Code for sales of goods, § 2-718(1): damages "may be liquidated in the agreement but only at an amount which is reasonable in the light of the anticipated or actual harm caused by the breach, the difficulties of proof of loss, and the inconvenience or nonfeasibility of otherwise obtaining an adequate remedy", and "a term fixing unreasonably large liquidated damages is void as a penalty". Courts apply the same reasoning to service contracts under common law. Most states ask some version of three questions:
- Was the loss hard to estimate when you signed? For a date booked a year out it usually is: nobody knows whether the date will be resold.
- Was the amount a reasonable forecast of that loss? Compared with your margin, the costs you'd already have spent, and how often dates get resold.
- Was it meant to compensate, or to scare the client into going ahead? Language and structure matter here. A clause that lets you choose between keeping the deposit or suing for more points to the second.
For goods (a made-to-order dress, printed stationery, a cake), § 2-718(2) adds a buyer's right to restitution: if you justifiably stop delivery because the buyer breached, they can recover what they paid beyond your liquidated damages, or, with no such clause, beyond 20% of the price or $500, whichever is smaller. Make sure goods-based deposits have a clear, reasonable liquidated-damages clause.
The label still matters less than people think. Some US practitioners for creative businesses prefer "retainer" to "deposit" because "deposit" can be read as refundable, but even they recommend defining the fee, saying why it is non-refundable and calling it liquidated damages (The Legal Paige). Our deposit vs retainer guide covers the labels in detail.
US: state rules and consumer laws
On top of the general rule, some states have specific rules. We list only ones we could read in the primary text or a law firm's published analysis; this isn't a 50-state survey.
- California
- For consumer contracts for services (bought "primarily for the party's personal, family, or household purposes"), a liquidated damages term "is void except" where "from the nature of the case, it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage" (Civil Code § 1671(c)–(d)). Business-to-business contracts get the looser test in § 1671(b): valid unless shown unreasonable. A wedding photographer selling to a couple is in the stricter group.
- Florida
- In Lefemine v. Baron, 573 So. 2d 326 (Fla. 1991), the Florida Supreme Court set a two-part test: damages must not be readily ascertainable, and the sum must not be "grossly disproportionate" to the damages reasonably expected. It also held a clause unenforceable where the seller could choose between keeping the deposit or suing for actual damages, because the option showed an intent to penalize (as summarized by Shutts & Bowen). The case was about real estate, but the reasoning is regularly applied to other contracts.
- Every state: sales away from your business
- The FTC's Cooling-Off Rule gives buyers until midnight of the third business day to cancel sales of $130 or more made at a seller's temporary location, such as "a hotel room, convention center, fairground, or restaurant", with a refund due within 10 days (FTC). A deposit taken at a wedding show isn't non-refundable until those 3 days pass.
- Every state: unfair and deceptive practices
- Each state has a consumer protection act banning unfair or deceptive practices, usually enforced by the attorney general and sometimes by private suits. Advertising "fully refundable" and then pointing to a non-refundable clause, or hiding the clause, is the kind of thing these laws catch. The details vary by state; ask a local attorney.
US vs UK side by side
| Question | US | UK |
|---|---|---|
| Main legal test | Liquidated damages vs penalty (state contract law; UCC § 2-718 for goods) | Fairness under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, plus the common-law penalty rule |
| Who enforces | Courts in private disputes; state attorneys general under consumer protection acts | Courts; the CMA (now with direct fines) and local Trading Standards |
| Common in practice | No set figure; a share you can explain from lost bookings and costs. 20–50% is common in wedding trades | "A small percentage of the price" (CMA). Fixed £500–£2,000 is common for venues |
| Bigger payments kept on cancellation | Enforceable if a reasonable pre-estimate of loss; a sliding scale helps | Only to the extent of your net loss after savings and rebooking |
| If the date is rebooked | Courts may still enforce a reasonable clause, but a refund of what you recover makes it much safer | Expect to pass on what you recover, beyond the small deposit |
| If you cancel | Refund in full; you are the one in breach | Refund in full; one-sided terms are on the grey list (para 4) |
| If nobody can go ahead | Depends on the contract and the state's law on impossibility; say what happens in the contract | Swift, full refund, "including ... fees described as 'non-refundable'" (CMA37, 6.77) |
| Cooling-off | FTC 3-day rule for sales at temporary locations | 14 days for online or off-premises contracts, except date-specific catering, accommodation and leisure |
| Label ("retainer", "booking fee") | Helps a little if defined; substance still decides | Makes no difference; the CMA treats deposits, fees and prepayments alike |
Worked examples
These are illustrations of how the rules apply, not predictions of what a court would decide. Small facts change outcomes.
1. UK venue, £15,000 booking, £1,500 deposit, cancelled 14 months ahead
The couple pays a £1,500 non-refundable deposit (10%) and two instalments of £2,000. Fourteen months before the date they split up and cancel by email. The venue resells the date three months later.
- The deposit: likely keepable. It is a fixed reservation sum, 10% of the price, explained at booking and lost only if the couple cancel. That fits CMA37 para 6.62.
- The £4,000 of instalments: should be refunded. Fourteen months out, the venue has spent little and resold the date. Keeping them would be a charge "for services which have not been supplied" (grey list para 5).
- Result: keep £1,500, refund £4,000 promptly. If the venue had spent money specifically on this wedding (a custom marquee order, say) it could keep that too, with receipts.
2. UK photographer, £3,000 package, 50% "non-refundable retainer"
The client pays £1,500 at booking and cancels 11 months before the date. Nothing has been done except a 30-minute call.
- £1,500 is half the price. That is not "a small percentage" and, 11 months out, it is far more than the photographer has lost. Renaming it a retainer makes no difference in UK law.
- If challenged, a small claims judge could treat the whole term as unfair. An unfair term isn't cut down to a fair level; it simply doesn't bind the consumer, so the photographer would have to justify any amount kept as real loss.
- Safer structure: a £300–£450 reservation deposit (10–15%), with the rest of the price paid in instalments and covered by a sliding scale that rises as the date approaches. See the policy generator.
3. California photographer, $8,000 package, $2,400 retainer, cancelled 13 months ahead
The couple signs a contract calling the $2,400 (30%) a non-refundable retainer and cancels 13 months before the date.
- This is a consumer contract for services, so Civil Code § 1671(d) applies: the clause is void unless actual damage would be "impracticable or extremely difficult to fix".
- The photographer's argument: a Saturday in peak season is booked once, enquiries for it were turned away, and nobody can know whether it will be rebooked. If she has a log of declined enquiries and her contract explains this, she has a real case.
- The couple's argument: 13 months is plenty of time to rebook, and the photographer did rebook. If the date was resold at full price, keeping the whole $2,400 is hard to defend.
- Practical answer: a clause that keeps a smaller amount (for example 15–20%) and refunds what a rebooking recovers is much more likely to survive than one that keeps 30% no matter what.
4. Florida venue, $25,000 wedding, "keep all payments or sue for more"
The contract says that if the couple cancels, the venue "may retain all payments as liquidated damages or, at its option, pursue all remedies available at law". The couple cancels 7 months out having paid $10,000.
- Under Lefemine v. Baron, giving the business the option to keep the payments or sue for actual damages shows an intent to penalize, and Florida courts have held such clauses unenforceable.
- If the clause fails, the venue doesn't lose everything, but it must prove its actual damages, which is slower and often worth less than a clean clause would have been.
- Fix: one remedy only. An agreed sliding scale, stated as the venue's liquidated damages, with no "or sue for more".
5. Your venue floods three weeks before the date
The couple has paid £9,000 including a £1,000 non-refundable deposit. The venue can't host the wedding.
- UK: refund everything, deposit included, promptly and with no admin fee (CMA37, para 6.77). Offering a new date is fine as an option, not as the only choice.
- US: the result depends on the contract and the state's law on impossibility. A clause saying what happens (new date first, then a refund less documented unrecoverable costs) gives both sides certainty. With no clause, expect to refund.
Evidence that keeps a deposit safe
Disputes are won on paper. If a client challenges a deposit in small claims, through Trading Standards or as a card chargeback, these are the records that matter:
| Keep | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| The signed contract and the page they paid on | Shows the deposit and its terms were clear before payment. Card issuers want the full terms, not a link. |
| A log of enquiries you turned away for that date | Proves the date had value and holding it cost you something. |
| Costs you spent on this booking | Receipts for supplier orders, hours of planning or design. Supports keeping more than the deposit. |
| Whether and when you rebooked the date, and for how much | In the UK you'll need to account for it; in the US it is the first thing the client will ask. |
| How you set the deposit amount | A short note of your reasoning (costs plus a share of the date's value) shows it is a pre-estimate, not a penalty. |
| The cancellation notice and your reply | Dates decide which band of the sliding scale applies. |
If the client paid by card, a dispute can take the money back before any court hears the case. Our guide to deposit chargebacks covers how to answer one.
Deposit wording that holds up
A single deposit clause for each country. They are deliberately short; the full policy with a sliding scale, date changes and instalments comes from the generator.
US
You pay a deposit of [$1,200] when you sign. It reserves your date, and we turn away other clients who ask for it. If you cancel, we keep the deposit as liquidated damages: our reasonable estimate, made today, of the loss of holding your date, which is hard to measure in advance. It counts toward your total price. If we cancel, or can't provide the service, we refund it in full.
UK
You pay a deposit of [£750] when you book. It reserves your date, and we turn away other clients who ask for it, so it is non-refundable if you cancel. We have kept it to a small part of the price. It counts toward your total price. If we cancel, or if events outside your control and ours stop the booking going ahead, we refund it in full along with everything else you have paid.
How Paid Up fits
Paid Up takes the deposit and then collects the rest of the price on a schedule that finishes before the service date, by card or US bank debit (ACH). Before the first payment, each client agrees to a payment plan agreement that says the deposit secures the date and is non-refundable if they cancel, that it is refunded in full if you cancel, and how a sliding scale applies to the other payments. In the UK version the deposit is described as "a reasonable booking fee" and cancellation charges are limited to actual losses, capped by band. We keep the exact text they agreed to.
Limits: the wording is our standard agreement and can't yet be replaced with your own, and refunds are made per payment in full, so a partial refund of one payment is done outside Paid Up. Neither Paid Up nor the agreement decides whether your deposit amount is fair; that's down to the number you choose.
Questions people ask
Is a non-refundable deposit legal?
Yes, in both the US and the UK, as long as the amount is reasonable for what it does (holding a date and covering the loss of turning other clients away) and the client agreed to it clearly before paying. Calling a payment non-refundable doesn't make it so: courts look at the amount and the circumstances, not the label.
Can a business keep my deposit if I cancel a year before the wedding?
Usually yes, if it is a modest reservation deposit set out in the contract. In the UK, the CMA expects it to be a small percentage of the price. Larger sums kept a year out, when the business has spent little and can rebook the date, are much more likely to be challenged.
Do I have to refund a non-refundable deposit if I cancel?
Yes. If you cancel or can't provide the service, refund it. The UK grey list targets terms that let a business keep money when the consumer cancels without giving equivalent compensation when the business cancels, and US courts won't let you keep a deposit for a contract you broke.
What percentage non-refundable deposit is reasonable?
There is no legal number for services. In the UK the CMA says a genuine deposit will not normally be more than a small percentage of the price; many UK venues take a fixed £500 to £2,000. In the US, 20% to 50% is common, but what holds up is an amount you can explain from your own costs and lost bookings.
Can I keep the deposit if the client's payment plan fails?
If the contract says a missed payment that isn't put right after notice counts as a cancellation, the normal cancellation terms apply, including the deposit. Give written notice and a fair time to pay first.
Is a non-refundable deposit the same as a retainer or booking fee?
The labels differ, and some US practitioners prefer "retainer", but courts in both countries look at what the money is for and whether the amount is proportionate. See our deposit vs retainer guide for the differences, including tax.
Sources
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 62: unfair terms are not binding on the consumer; the fairness test (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1: grey list paras 4, 5 and 6 on keeping sums paid and disproportionate compensation (read Nov 17, 2026)
- CMA, Unfair contract terms guidance (CMA37), revised 22 July 2026: paras 6.59–6.67 (prepayments, deposits, termination fees), 6.76–6.77 (frustration), 1.11–1.12 (penalties and repayment) (read Nov 17, 2026)
- CMA, advisory letter to wedding and event venue providers (2 March 2016): deposits as a small reservation fee; net loss after savings and rebooking (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Cavendish Square Holding BV v Makdessi; ParkingEye v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67: para 32 (the penalty test), para 16 (a deposit can be a penalty), para 35 (Workers Trust: 10% customary deposit upheld, 25% struck down) (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Citizens Advice, Cancelling a service you've arranged: what consumers are told about deposits and cancellation charges (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Uniform Commercial Code § 2-718 (Cornell LII): reasonable liquidated damages; penalty rule; buyer's restitution of deposits on goods (read Nov 17, 2026)
- California Civil Code § 1671: consumer contracts: liquidated damages void unless actual damage is impracticable or extremely difficult to fix (read Nov 17, 2026)
- Menor and Jones (Shutts & Bowen), "Can I Have My Deposit Back?", ActionLine, Winter 2015: Florida's two-part test in Lefemine v. Baron, 573 So. 2d 326 (Fla. 1991) and the option-to-sue trap (read Nov 17, 2026)
- FTC, Buyer's Remorse: the FTC's Cooling-Off Rule: 3-day right to cancel sales at temporary locations ($130+) (read Nov 17, 2026)
- The Legal Paige, Deposits vs Retainers: Are They Refundable? (30 May 2023): a US practitioner's view that clear liquidated-damages wording matters more than the label (read Nov 17, 2026)
About this page
General information, not legal advice. Contract law differs between US states and between England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, and the outcome of any dispute depends on its facts. Ask a lawyer or solicitor to check your deposit terms. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at [email protected] and we'll correct it.
Take a fair deposit, then let the rest collect itself.
Clients sign an agreement with a deposit clause and a sliding cancellation scale before the first payment. Start on the Free plan.